You told my mother you'd be back for your birthday
When she told me, I laughed at your wordplay
I still wanted you back in the worst way, though
I'm so typical

Don't call me a moment
Don't call me your friend
Don't call me a story
'Cause stories end
Don't call me the most
When I feel like a ghost then
But if you wanna, guess that you could call me when

You come back, come back to the valley
Come back, come back to the valley
Come back, come back to the valley
If you wanna, guess that you could, guess that you could call me when
You come back, come back, come back
Come back, come back, come back
Come back, come back, come back
If you wanna, guess that you could, guess that you could call me then

I've never felt like this for anyone
I hate it, it scares me when I say it
Dark hair, denim jacket, stupid smile, I gotta have it
I'd never tell you, but it's tempting me again

Don't call me a moment
Don't call me your friend
Don't call me a story
'Cause stories end
Don't call me the most
When I feel like a ghost then
But if you wanna, guess that you could call me when

You come back, come back to the valley
Come back, come back to the valley
Come back, come back to the valley
If you wanna, guess that you could, guess that you could call me when (guess that you could call me when)
You come back, come back, come back
Come back, come back, come back
Come back, come back, come back
If you wanna, guess that you could, guess that you could call me then

Not gonna lie, I like your name on my phone
So, light it up, light it up, light me up the way you did before

You come back, come back to the valley
Come back, come back to the valley
Come back, come back to the valley (come back to the valley)
If you wanna, guess that you could, guess that you could call me when
You come back, come back, come back
Come back, come back, come back
Come back, come back, come back
If you wanna, guess that you could, guess that you could call me then (guess that you could call me then)