First time's a charm You called me when you got off work Told me that you don't make first moves But when I tried to kiss you, you moved? Every time you came to visit me in Orange County You could tell my body count was up and counting Counting Every time I came to visit you in Santa Monica The local boys all said they really wanted ya Oh, I really wanted ya Tell me, baby Is there something you'd like to know? Tell me, baby Is there somewhere you'd like to go? I vote in the back of your office Second time's a charm You said you wanna go out for drinks You ended up getting a headache So we watched La La Land in my bed instead Third time's a charm 'Cause you're on my arm We're in my car You're playing my songs I think it's funny! I think it's funny! All the songs that you write are about girls What about Puzzle? Ok, I'm sorry Most of the songs I write are about girls? How 'bout we make this one about you After all the things we haven't been through Yoga pants and red lipstick That's enough to make me miss