You had a dream she was a dancer
Some kind of New York dancer that was a light sleeper
We were a disaster
Anyone can ask and get all the same answers
A blue champagne glass that I thought was plastic
Now all of the warnings and all of the signs
I tried hard to hide this and tried to be kind
And I tried not to smile and I tried not to laugh
When I broke your favorite blue champagne glass
Oh no

Might've been some dancing but not New York dancing
This was not romantic, this was never planned
Anyone can ask and get all the same answers
A blue champagne glass that I thought was plastic
Now all of the warnings and all of the signs
I tried hard to hide this and tried to be kind
And I tried not to smile and I tried not to laugh
When I broke your favorite blue champagne glass

Now I forever will be
Heartbreaker breaking your things.
Now I forever will be how you would remember that dream

Now all of my love to you
Now all of my love to you

Because when I lie, I forever will be
Heartbreaker breaking your things
Now I forever will be how you would remember that dream